Wines Rated 90+

  • Orin Swift 2023 Eight Years in the Desert

    Orin Swift 2023 Eight Years in the Desert

    Price range: $39.99 through $210.00

    California
    The 2023 Eight Years in the Desert pours a dark mauve core with a red amethyst rim and aromatic notes of ripe blackberry and raspberry bramble. Further hints of chocolate covered espresso bean, black pepper and allspice emanate from the glass. The entry is dominated by black plum preserves and freshly baked mixed berry morning bun with an energetic yet concentrated mid-palate. Soft and textured tannins give way to a lifted finish with a touch of pluot and dried tarragon.
    Must be ordered.
    Valid while supplies are available
    Buy this one by the 6pk for $35.00 bottle

  • Orin Swift 2023 Sign of the Times Red Blend

    Orin Swift 2023 Sign of the Times Red Blend

    Price range: $29.99 through $168.00

    California
    Decanter Magazine 94 Rating
    This is a full-bodied, dark-fruited and remarkably approachable red wine from Dave Phinney, whose deft touch has turned this blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Petite Sirah and Grenache into a decadent, layered wine. Plush notes of graphite and dark chocolate dominate, while the bright red-fruited character of the Grenache shines through, interwoven with violet and dried rose petal aromatics. A pronounced mineral streak—reminiscent of incense or wet slate—adds intrigue, and the finish is long and satisfying, supported by a firm spine of tangy blood orange acidity. A truly impressive effort from Phinney, wrapped in an eye-catching label.
    Must be ordered.
    Valid while supplies are available
    Buy this one by the 6pk for $28.00 per bottle

  • Ornellaia 2018 Tenuta dell'Ornellaia Bolgheri Superiore

    Ornellaia 2018 Tenuta dell’Ornellaia Bolgheri Superiore

    $229.99

    Tuscany Italy
    Wine Spectator 95 Rating
    Complex, sophisticated and harmonious, this pure red is marked by black currant, black cherry, cedar, iron and light spice flavors. Bright and focused, with refined tannins emerging on the spice-tinged finish. Discreet and stylish. Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot. Best from 2023 through 2040. SP47-2

  • Ornellaia 2021 Bolgheri Superiore

    Ornellaia 2021 Bolgheri Superiore

    $249.99

    Tuscany Italy
    Wine Spectator 98 Rating
    An intense red, defined by lively acidity and framed by dense, ripe tannins that showcase its black currant, blackberry, violet and toasty oak aromas and flavors. Iron and wild herb accents emerge as this plays out on the finish. Though expressive at this stage, this youthful version will benefit from time in bottle. Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot. Best from 2027 through 2046. SP42-3

  • Othello by Dominus 2021 Bordeaux Red Blend

    Othello by Dominus 2021 Bordeaux Red Blend

    $44.99

    Napa Valley California
    James Suckling 96 Rating
    Lots of blackberries, dark cherries and hints of orange peel and bark in the aromas. Medium- to full-bodied with fine creamy tannins that caress the palate. The tannic tension gives this focus and brightness. 85% cabernet sauvignon, 9% cabernet franc and the rest petit verdot. Hard not to drink now, but better in two to three years. R38-2 BX-6

  • Pago del Vicario 2023 Blanco de Tempranillo

    Pago del Vicario 2023 Blanco de Tempranillo

    Price range: $15.99 through $78.00

    Vino de Pago La Mancha Spain
    Decanter Magazine 95 Rating
    Pale straw yellow with greenish reflections. Aromas of ripe pear and ripe citrus zest mingle with slight floral notes and touches of tropical fruit, such as green mango. Bold flavor on the palate, full of green apple, white peach, dried herbs, green olive and bitter almond with a captivating minerality that powers the long, lively finish.
    Must be ordered.
    Valid while supplies are available
    Buy this one by the 6pk for $13.00 bottle

  • Pahlmeyer 2019 Proprietary Red Wine

    Pahlmeyer 2019 Proprietary Red Wine

    $214.99

    Napa Valley
    James Suckling 98 Rating
    Blackberries, blackcurrants and hints of mint. Full-bodied with very fine, velvety tannins. Turns firm and structured with a fine chewiness and a caressing mouth-feel. Lively, too…Very attractive now, but will be better in four to five years. Try after 2026. R9-5

  • Paitin 2015 Serraboella Barbaresco

    Paitin 2015 Serraboella Barbaresco

    $44.99

    Piedmont Italy
    Wine Spectator 94 Rating
    Hay, freshly cut grass and loam aromas segue to a core of cherry that pulls this together. The sweet fruit handles the burly tannins well, ending in a cascade of eucalyptus and tobacco notes. Best from 2023 through 2043. R10-2

  • Palermo 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley

    Palermo 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley

    Price range: $39.99 through $456.00

    California
    A dark garnet core with a brooding cardinal rim, the 2022 Palermo opens with notes of crunchy cassis, muddled boysenberry, ripe elderberry chaparral and cedar. The palate continues many of the aromatics with traces of cassis, blackberry, savory and thyme. Effuse with ripe dark fruits but also complex savory tones, the wine closes with long and soft tannin chains and hints of licorice, black pepper and star anise.
    Must be ordered.
    Valid while supplies are available
    Buy this one by the 12pk for $38.00 per bottle